Are you craving the best burger on Anna Maria Island? You’ve come to the right place! We’ve rounded up four burger joints that’ll have your mouth watering. From classic beach shacks to spots with a gourmet twist, these places serve burgers that locals and visitors rave about. Get ready for a burger experience you won’t forget!
4 Spots to Enjoy the Best Burger on Anna Maria Island
Skinny’s Place
3901 Gulf Dr, Holmes Beach – (941) 778-7769
Enjoy a juicy, perfectly grilled burger in your hands while enjoying the island atmosphere on AMI. That’s the vibe at Skinny’s Place. This classic 1950s beach shack may not look fancy, but its burgers are legendary. Each bite packs a no-nonsense burger flavor that hits all the right spots.
Locals swear by it, and visitors come back year after year for that unbeatable combo of simple, delicious food and beach vibes. Pro tip: Hit Skinny’s on a weekday to avoid the crowds and enjoy your burger peacefully.
Check our showcased review of Skinny’s:
“Hands down, the best burger on the island! Thin, perfectly cooked patties with melted cheese, toasted buns, and the right amount of crunch. Quick service, cold drinks, and shady seats make Skinny’s the ultimate burger shack. I’ve told everyone about it, and I’m already planning my next visit!” – P.S., 5 Stars
Duffy’s Tavern
5808 Marina Dr, Holmes Beach – (941) 778-2501
Duffy’s Tavern isn’t just any burger joint. It is known for serving a “world-famous burger” and the coldest beer on the island. Their grill has been cooking up fresh ground beef patties for decades. The result is a burger that’s juicy, flavorful, and downright addictive. Once you sink your teeth into one of their burgers, you’ll understand why people have been flocking here since 1958. It’s a true burger lover’s paradise.
Smoqehouse
1701 Gulf Dr N, Bradenton Beach – (941) 242-5340
For those who like their burgers with a smoky twist, Smoqehouse is your spot. Their brisket burger is a game-changer. It’s packed with flavor and topped with smoked cheddar, caramelized onions, and their signature Smoq sauce. Their hand-cut fries are a perfect match for this BBQ-inspired burger masterpiece. The rustic, laid-back atmosphere just adds to the appeal. Once you’ve tried their brisket burger, it’s hard to go back to anything else.
The Porch Restaurant
9707 Gulf Dr, Anna Maria – (941) 782-8683
Vegans and vegetarians, don’t worry—The Porch Restaurant has you covered. While most burger joints focus on beef patties, The Porch offers a delicious beet burger for plant-based eaters. It isn’t just any veggie burger—it’s flavorful, hearty, and satisfying enough to rival any meat-based option. Set in one of the oldest homes on the island, The Porch combines historic charm with modern flavors. The outdoor deck also provides a great atmosphere for your meal.
If you’re serious about your burgers, Anna Maria Island won’t disappoint. So go ahead—explore these local gems and satisfy those burger cravings. You won’t regret it!
Book Your Ideal Vacation Rental!
Are you looking for a place to stay during your next AMI vacation? Click here to find vacation rentals on Anna Maria Island. You can also contact our team for help finding the right booking.
Thanks for visiting!
